Expanding agriculture and animal farming often removes natural habitats and reduces natural biodiversity. Issues affecting the future of agriculture and food. Department of agriculture rural development rural businesscooperative service research report 192 september 2002. Aware of our interdependence, we acknowledge that eating ethically requires us to be mindful of the miracle of life we share with all beings. The goal of this journal is to create a forum for discussion of moral issues arising from actual or projected social policies in regard to a wide range of questions. In his food for thought lecture, rob discuses why, after embracing agricultural science to become well. All areas of human endeavor rely upon ideals of value, right action and purpose including agriculture and the development of food systems. In such a society, interdependence would be recognized as inescapable, each individual would be granted personal autonomy and dignity, and states would be able to maintain their sovereignty. Ethical issues in agricultural production and education. Issues affecting the future of agriculture and food security. It became clear that multiple values informed alternative visions of agriculture and food i. It includes summaries of historical approaches, current scholarship, social movements, and new trends from the standpoint of the ethical notions that have shaped them. Historically, those involved in food production, research, or education have had limited involvement in ethical discussions there is a perception that provision of food for humanity was important to the greater good of society how could there be any ethical or moral issues associated with the reduction or elimination of.
Agnes is a 32yearold ghanaian woman living in a small village 100 miles from the nations capital, accra. The agriculture, food, and human values society, for instance, was formed in 1987 to promote the study of values issues associated with the production, consumption, and distribution of food, fiber, and natural resources. Using late potato blight which accounts for half of all fungicide application in norwegian agriculture as an example, myhr introduced a list of questions that may be considered when deciding whether to approve gmo potatoes that are resistant to the fungus, including the consideration of socioeconomic issues, sustainability and the role. Catholic rural life is a longtime advocate on behalf of family farmers and farm communities. But food and agriculture, and the economic benefits that derive from participation in the food and agriculture system, are means to ends that are inherently ethical in nature. These essays have been solicited from people who have thought about the choices we face and the decisions we must make as we try to balance feeding the worlds expected 9 billion people with the need to preserve the food.
But its hard to find a proorganic website that doesnt have some sort of claim however vague about the health benefits of organic food. Ethics in agricultural biotechnology therefore encompass value judgments that cover the production, processing, and distribution of food and agricultural products. Given the traditions and special requirements of agricultural research planning, utilitarian theory is well adapted to serve as a starting point for evaluating these decisions, but utilitarianism has. Encyclopedia of food and agricultural ethics springerlink. Food labelling rules in australia state that the nine most common allergens peanut, tree nuts, milk, egg, fish, shellfish, wheat, sesame and soy must be declared on packaging. Interdisciplinary and sustainability issues in food and agriculture human nutrition. Nonprofit, apolitical, independent, and nongovernmental in nature, the uia has been a pioneer in the. Ethics and genetically modified foods gary comstock iowa state university ames, ia much of the food consumed in the united states is genetically modified gm, i. The relationship of nutrition to the food and healthrelated industries also comes with a set of ethical obligations. Ethical issues in food and agriculture fao ethics series by food and agriculture organization of the united nations author isbn. This barcode number lets you verify that youre getting exactly the right version or edition of a book. I ethical issues in agriculture herwig grimm encyclopedia of life support systems eolss activities have rarely been addressed within the realm of ethics. In industrialized agriculture and increasingly in smallholder exportoriented agriculture, improving the situation of agricultural labor entails building fundamental ethical principles into food production systems based on human rights, as outlined in international labor organization conventions.
Genetically modified food markkula center for applied ethics. Ethical questions of equitable worldwide food production systems. Ag 401 ethical issues in food, agricultural, and apparel. Utilitarian ethics provides a model for evaluating moral responsibility in agricultural research decisions according to the balance of costs and benefits accruing to the public at large. The study was designed to assess potential influences by sponsors regarding the health effects related to consuming 1 of 3 beverages soft drinks, milk, and juice. In his food for thought lecture, rob discuses why, after embracing agricultural science to become well fed, those in wealthy. Sustainable agriculture is in fact, a growing industry and young entrepreneurs especially are grabbing hold of this food first trend. In other words, an ethical food and agriculture system must help citizens, communities, nations and the world as a whole progress from a global economy towards a truly global society. Given the traditions and special requirements of agricultural research planning, utilitarian theory is well adapted to serve as a starting point for evaluating these decisions, but utilitarianism has defects. The future of sustainability our population trajectory means that from now to 2030, the world will need to build the equivalent of a city of one million people in developing countries, every five days. Apr 15, 2005 but the california food and agriculture department denied ventrias request after rice growers expressed concern that international customers would refuse their rice out of fear of contamination.
Ethical issues in food and agriculture pdf agriculture. This encyclopedia offers a definitive source on issues pertaining to the full range of topics in the important new area of food and agricultural ethics. Going back to the tale of upton sinclairs the jungle, through food borne illness outbreaks, the increasing number of recalls, to modern documentaries like food inc. It remains unclear if technical progress could inspire more positive opinions.
Dec 19, 2012 bioethics colloquium with marion nestle almost anything related to food raises ethics issues of one kind or another. Food and agriculture matters 8 land reforms can give fairer access to rural land rural investment can deter unmanageable urbanization of the food we produce is lost or wasted agriculture is key in responding to climate change fish gives 3 bn. However often your local farmers farm to organic standards but arent. Ethical issues in food and agriculture pdf free download as pdf file. Our advocacy work for fair and just federal policies on agriculture and nutrition programsespecially the farm billis highly regarded by family farmers and faithbased groups alike. Ethical concerns in this light become the subject of political claims and regulatory demands. The resolution of these issues demands careful reflection and constructive dialogue the purpose of this new series on ethics in food and agriculture is to give impetus to that dialogue. The union of international associations uia is a research institute and documentation centre, based in brussels.
Analysis of topics in biotechnology in agricultural production and food processing, intellectual and physical property rights in a market based economy, human nutrition problems, the treatment of animals and the environment, worker rights in a global food and apparel marketplace, and americas role in reducing world hunger and malnutrition. Getting real about the high price of cheap food a collection of stories catologing the collateral damage of modern food production. Ethical food and agriculture archives catholic rural life. Ethical issues in food and agriculture pdf agriculture foods. Ethics of organic farming the business ethics blog. Pdf ethical concerns associated with organic food in europe.
Despite the current buzz about the failure of prop 37 to pass, the agriculture reform, food and jobs act 2012, commonly known as the farm bill, has been on the minds of everyone in the food community, as its expiration on october, 1 st of this year went by without the passing of a new bill. The encyclopedia of world problems and human potential is a unique, experimental research work of the union of international associations. Ethical issues in food and agriculture fao ethics series. The relation between these concerns and the markets constituting the agrifood system are understood in very different ways. Lincoln gave a speech that was widely understood to express his vision for the usda. I need to name a few ethical issues of food production in relation to any of the following. Sociocultural development and food and agriculture 4. Underwood,president, international union of nutritional sciences, and scholarinresidence, food and nutrition board, institute of medicine, national academies washington, d.
Ethical questions of equitable worldwide food production. Advocating for sustainable agriculture and nutritious food for all. Bioethics colloquium with marion nestle almost anything related to food raises ethics issues of one kind or another. Interviews with staff members revealed that although ethics as a. A second line of argument is that agriculture and food should be understood. The traditional links between agricultural raw materials and food products have been progressively eroded in a process in which farm products are. This paper addresses ethical questions as they relate to the mandate of the food and agriculture organization of the united nations. Farmers are faced with issues impacting agriculture, including new challenges and opportunities every day from feeding an expanding global population while meeting strict new emissions requirements, to producing more food on fewer acres while minimizing their environmental footprint. Not surprisingly, recent develop ments have brought to the fore numerous ethical issues that are central to food security and to sustainable rural development and. Ethical issues in historical and sociological perspective john wilkinson principles and perceptions. Two years ago, scientists from an international organization approached her. For us, sustainable agriculture means employing a wide range. The use of food additives has been integral to developments in the global food industry over recent decades, which are characterized by terms such as agribusiness and food processing. Recent problems with pet food in france nestle fined for over pricing and fix pricing food because there is not much competition at the moment and they think that they should take this opportunity to make more profit fined over 19million euros nestle buys water for about 1 a penny per gallon and sells it back for ten dollars.
It is currently published as a searchable online platform with profiles of world problems, action strategies, and human values that are interlinked in novel and innovative ways. About us croplife international is a global network of plant science companies and regional and national crop protection and biotechnology associations that share the common goal of creating and promoting solutions for sustainable agriculture. The pitches addressed some of todays most pressing issues in the food and agriculture industries. There is widespread consensus that, going forward, farmers must produce more food per unit of land, water, and. Only on a few occasions has fao considered ethical values, although they are embedded in the preamble to the organizations constitution. This course explores ethical theories, concepts of critical thinking, and major ethical issues in american agriculture as well as global agriculture. A study by lesser et al in part addresses this point. The food and agriculture organization of the united nations asserts that ethical values determine its reason for being these being the values for food, enhanced wellbeing, human health, natural resources, and nature fao, 2001. However, food and agriculture, and the economic benefits that derive from participation in the food and agriculture system, are means to ends that are inherently ethical in nature. In addition food borne diseases that cause public issues and ecosystem challenges can often be traced to industrial animal agriculture.
Analysis of topics in biotechnology in agricultural production and food processing, intellectual and physical property rights. The journal of agricultural and environmental ethics presents articles on ethical issues confronting agriculture, food production and environmental concerns. In the world of the multination producers of food, we have to analyze the site of the producers, the consumers, scientists, political leaders, and the most important of all the ethical issues implicated. Ngos adverse positions, stemming from ethical concerns on health and environmental safety issues, have been influential in the 1999 eu moratorium on gm food and crops. There are many scientists who argue that genetic engineering in agriculture is the best way to solve many issues of poverty, food security, environmental harm, and the need for increasing competitiveness in sales, but others raise ethical issues regarding the health of the people who consume. Ag 401 ethical issues in food, agricultural, and apparel industries 4 socioeconomic and scientific issues in the food, agricultural, and apparel systems within a framework of moral philosophy and ethical reasoning. The purpose of this paper is to suggest how the thematic issues in each section are related to the future of agriculture and food security in europe west and east and central asia. Many of the issues at the forefront of discussion in american agriculture today are ethical issues. Agricultural biotechnology, policies, ethics, and policy. Because of growing concerns over food safety and security, and recognizing the role of the farmer within the agricultural system, it is imperative. With gratitude for the food we have received, we strive to choose foods that minimize harm and are protective of the environment, consumers, farmers, and all those involved in food production and distribution. Gm food is often seen as not useful, morally unacceptable and a risk for society. This is a phenomenal trend, one that has been building slowly, and that we should all support and get behind because there is plenty more work to be done.
In spite of the modern international food systems initial association with free trade and the later efforts to reinsert agriculture and food within an exclusively market logic, the ethical priorities enshrined in the adoption of the principles of food security and sustainability have established a common normative baseline for agriculture and. Following this, the current situation is examined and specific issues are analyzed. On the one hand, some see the very act of using genetic technology to raise ethical issues that would. The way we regulate food and agricultural systems is inherently of ethical concern. I just dont really understand the question in relation to food production. These include ones that we are familiar with the place of corporations in u. Ethical and social challenges of agricultural technologies. The major social, political, economic, and ethical issues that arise in connection to the food and fiber system are examined and potential solutions considered. The society sponsors an annual conference and publishes a refereed quarterly journal, agriculture and human values. Interdisciplinary and sustainability issues in food and agriculture contents volume i development issues in food and agriculture 1 olaf christen, institute of agronomy and crop science, university of hallewittenberg, germany 1. Salmonella, clostridium perfringens, campylobacter, staphylococcus aureus, e. Their concerns can be classified into two broad categories. These ethical problems presuppose notions of justice, human rights, dignity of people, and quality of food and livelihood.
Ethics assessment in different fields agricultural. Earlier this week 41205, brewer anheuserbusch threatened to boycott rice from missouri if ventria is allowed to set up its biopharming. These foodand agricultural issues are also bound up with issues of governance, trade, culture, and religion. Some food such as foods sold fresh in delicatessens must either have ingredients displayed or have ingredients available in case a customer asks about allergen content. These sections of the paper state the basic issues under each theme, outline the latest literature on the subtopics, discuss the main issues that are. Eating better than organic the debate between local food and largescale distant shipped organic rages.
She cultivates and harvests maize zea mays, cassava manihot esculenta crantz. In europe, operators can only label a food product as organic, when they follow the. An additional environmental concern is the deterioration of the oceans and their life forms due to overfishing and pollution. This is an informal introduction to a series of essays on agricultural ethics. Going back to the tale of upton sinclairs the jungle, through food borne illness outbreaks, the increasing number of recalls, to modern documentaries like food inc eating better than organic the debate between local food and largescale distant. Organizations representing the organic agriculture industry are careful not to make health claims for organic foods and indeed, in some juristictions such claims are forbidden by law. First, the values central to food and agriculture are identified. Debates on the future of the agrifood system have been accompanied by an increasing focus on ethical concerns which in the recent period have centered around the concept and the political goal of food security maye and kirwan, 20. Scholars,activists, and citizens increasingly question the goals and ethical rationale behind production, distribution, and consumptionoffood,as wellasthe useofcrops forfueland. Agriculture ettore capri ethical issues for food safety in the context of global food security clare narrod the global agrifood system food security and the global agrifood system. Funding solutions for pressing food and agriculture issues.
1046 473 335 39 570 116 1118 154 653 711 1046 14 653 674 315 840 669 645 1279 803 644 1248 1303 770 852 450 152 1451